AI Orientation in practice: a recap of our webinar
We recently hosted a webinar led by Ben Williams, Chief Scientist at Unseen, on how employers can assess the psychological factors that shape people’s approach to AI, alongside their current AI skills.
AI capability describes what someone knows and can do with AI today. It can be important when a role requires a particular skill from day one, but platform-specific measures may not transfer to other tools, and tests of technical skills can date quickly as technology changes.
AI Orientation offers a broader view. The webinar introduced three related areas:
Dispositions and personality: ways of thinking, feeling and behaving.
AI-specific motivation and confidence: whether someone sees value in learning, feels able to do so and is willing to invest effort.
Attitudes, values and beliefs: what someone trusts about AI, how they view its consequences and which uses they consider acceptable.
These areas can help explain why people with similar skills may respond differently to new AI tasks. What they do not do is point to one ideal AI profile, instead, the role should determine which aspects matter.
Ben then outlined how employers can put AI Orientation into practice: start with job analysis, establish the capabilities needed on entry, identify which aspects of AI Orientation matter for the role, and choose suitable ways to assess them.
How can an organisation assess AI Orientation when they have hundreds of roles?
Ben’s answer was to balance consistency with enough detail to reflect the work:
Look for clusters of roles and the requirements they share.
Apply more detail where AI use has different or more significant implications.
Avoid both a bespoke assessment for every role and treating every role as identical.
This is a pragmatic way to decide what can be assessed consistently and where a role needs closer attention, rather than a fixed formula for grouping jobs.
Can AI Orientation develop after someone is hired?
One employer asked about development over time and specifically what to do when employee attitudes change, for example if they become more cynical about AI. Ben noted that the right response depends on the organisation and why attitudes have changed. There is no single intervention that will shift every team’s views.
Personality tends to be more stable, while confidence, motivation and ethical views can change with experience and context. Development conversations can explore what is behind a person’s response. For example, someone who doubts they can learn a new tool might reflect on a time they successfully learned new technology. Someone who sees little value in AI, or objects to a particular use, needs a different discussion.
What if a candidate objects to AI in selection?
Ben shared a recent story from an event where a panel of students said they might react negatively to AI in recruitment, including on environmental grounds. Other candidates may welcome AI in selection because they expect a quicker process or believe it could reduce bias.
Employers should understand whether the concern is about the selection method, a particular tool or AI use in the job, then assess candidates against the actual role requirements using consistent evidence.
How to drive authenticity & connection with
employee-generated
content
A psychological deep-dive into creating meaningful engagement with your employer brand
Organisations spend considerable time thinking about what they want candidates and employees to hear. But who communicates a message, how it is expressed and whose voices are represented can be just as important as the message itself.
This report, part of Unseen’s The Science of… series, brings together nine psychological principles surrounding the contributor and the audience. It offers a framework for understanding why the human experiences that employee-generated content makes visible truly matter, and how to put those principles into practice.
At its simplest, employee-generated content involves two people: someone being asked to share an experience (the contributor), and someone else being asked to make sense of what they see and hear (the audience). The two sets of principles are connected: How participation is designed influences whose voices are heard. The voices that are heard shape what audiences trust, connect with, and learn from.
The paper explores how the psychology of the contributor and the psychology of the audience work together, and how to apply each principle when designing an employee content project.
01 / CONTRIBUTOR
The psychology of the contributor
Four principles address the contributor’s questions: Can I do this? Do I understand what I’m being asked to do? Can I do this in a way that works for me? Is it normal and acceptable for someone like me to take part?
02 / AUDIENCE
The psychology of the audience
Five principles address the audience’s questions: Do I believe this? Do I connect with this? Can I see myself here? Is this actually right for me? Do people who work here appear to believe this too?
03 / PRACTICE
Putting the science into practice
The paper shows how to apply each principle when designing contribution projects, and how Unseen’s Seenit platform can support capture, editing and distribution of employee-generated video.
Small changes in the way you ask can make a big difference
Whether people contribute, and whether audiences believe what they hear, depends on how the request is framed and who is invited to speak. Open an example to see how the principle applies in practice.
“I don’t think I’ll be any good at it.”
Contributor Principle 1: Build confidence
Willingness and capability are different problems.
The barrier is not always “I don’t want to contribute”. Sometimes it is a belief that the contribution will not be good enough. Appropriate guidance, examples and support can strengthen confidence without taking the contributor’s voice away from them.
A useful starting point: give people an achievable first contribution and enough support to think, “I have something worth saying, and I can do this.”
“We provide extensive support to employees experiencing significant life events.”
An employee describing the support they actually received gives the statement evidence. Authenticity is an outcome of the process, not a production style, so production should support the employee’s voice rather than replace it.
A useful starting point: ask “What is something about working here that you didn’t expect before you joined?” rather than “Tell us why this is a great place to work.”
Illustrative examples drawn from The Science of Employee-Generated Content.
Turn employee voices into content that drives hiring and culture
Explore how technology and behavioural science can support employee storytelling, from hiring to engagement.
Volume-proofing the candidate experience: Key takeaways from our early careers breakfast
Applications numbers are still rising, competition is increasing and AI is changing recruitment processes faster than most employers can adapt.
These were some of the themes at our recent breakfast event, in partnership with the ISE, hosted at The Ivy in Tower Bridge.
Early careers leaders from industries across Finance, Retail, Engineering and more gathered to hear the latest findings from the ISE’s 2026 Student Recruitment Survey, explore the psychology behind the candidate experience, and compare approaches with one another. It was a fantastic opportunity to compare the quantitative data against what employers are seeing in their own processes.
Read on for the key findings, the discussions around the room and how business psychology and behavioural science can help employers respond to the latest market insights.
AI is disrupting process faster than it is being adopted
Dr Claire Tyler, Head of Insights at the ISE, presented findings from the latest Student Recruitment Survey. It drew responses from 155 employers, who received 1.7 million applications and made over 31,000 hires last year.
Employers are not managing candidate use of AI by simply adopting AI themselves. Whilst 77% are reviewing or redesigning their process as candidate use of AI climbs,, only 16% of employers use AI in recruitment today. The influence of AI is clearly extending beyond organisations actively deploying it in their recruitment process.
There’s been a significant shift in employer attitudes towards candidate use of AI, becoming more accepting that it has become part of students’ everyday lives.
64% are now comfortable with candidates using AI at some stage of the recruitment process, up from 46% last year. 82% provide guidance on how to use AI appropriately, compared with 55% in 2025.
At the same time, 92% of employers said they had encountered some form of cheating through the application and assessment process.
Discussions around the room
Where is the line on AI?
Several employers are testing and exploring using AI in recruitment rather than committing and governance is still a significant consideration for many.
There was also an interesting discussion on where automation ends and AI begins. Automation has long been part of recruitment, but now it seems the two are often being confused, with some candidates who receive automated responses assuming AI is involved. It was agreed, therefore, that the language employers use needs to be carefully considered, as well as some work from employers to increase understanding amongst candidates about the distinction between AI and automation.
Keeping assessments fair and human
Some employers have moved interviews to in-person after seeing candidates rely on AI during live conversations. Others have dropped recorded video interviews and virtual assessment centres. For both, the trade-off was cost and attendance levels. One employer reported 30% of candidates dropping out of in-person assessment centres, particularly where candidates had other offers that did not involve travel.
In a world where candidates are making many more applications than usual, it’s understood that they cannot realistically feel as strongly about every role they apply for – application volume alone does not secure the candidates employers want. Ben Williams, Chief Scientist at Unseen, took the group through the psychology behind the candidate experience and ways to improve candidate commitment throughout the process, including providing more realistic job previews, justifications of chosen assessment tools and sharing testimonials from relatable colleagues.
The next biggest theme was application volume and the impact it can have on the candidate experience.
It was found by the ISE that graduate hiring is stabilising, but that the growth remains uneven. Hiring rose by 4% this year after an 8% fall last year. The contraction has stopped, but growth is not returning across the board. When they exclude the small number of very large employers from the dataset, the average change is close to zero.
At the same time, volume of applications continues to be the key issue for employers. 73% of employers expect high application volumes to be a challenge in the next recruitment season, and 60% say managing high application numbers is a top concern for the next 5 years. Application numbers are still at a record high, with 141 per vacancy overall, rising to 172 in London.
Employers are responding to this by adjusting their processes using shorter application windows, basic screening automation and limits on how many roles a candidate can apply for. Using AI to manage volumes was low down on the list of adjustments being made, ranked 10th.
Discussions around the room
Consistent communication
After hearing the data, discussions turned to how this could be put into practice, particularly at scale.
It was agreed that automated messages to candidates can still be rich, tailored and informative, even when they’re not coming from an individual. One employer shared that they use a single recruiter to record a video with updates at each stage of the process, so candidates can feel better connected and valued by seeing the same person throughout.
The challenge of keeping candidate attendance during live events was brought up once more, and some employers shared that they have moved pre-joining webinars to pre-recorded sessions after seeing candidates drop out of live events.
Ben shared how a psychologically-informed journey design can help organisations maintain candidate attention and engagement across long lead times, rather than relying on isolated moments of communication. Unseen’s candidate and onboarding experience platform, Meet&Engage, facilitates this through staged content releases, reminder emails and notifications, structured content ordering and progressive engagement over time.
Delivering feedback at scale
Only 14% of employers in the ISE survey said they provided feedback at the initial screening stage, rising to 40% at testing. One employer shared how through utilising Unseen’s Assessment Centre platform, TopScore, they were able to easily provide quality feedback at every stage of the process and rarely saw any challenge on that feedback.
Another discussion was about the value of the data collected through assessment – one employer shared how they use assessment centre data to build a candidate profile at the end of the process, and everyone was in agreement that it would be useful to be able to join up that data with candidate strengths and improvement areas later down the line once they were in role.
How we can help
Volume-proofing the candidate experience means scaling processes without diluting the journey. Everything employers do needs to centre on being clear, relevant, human and trusted.
The topics covered at the breakfast are ones we work on with employers every day, from designing assessment journeys and feedback to keeping candidates engaged between stages and planning for volume.
If your team is facing similar pressures, we would welcome a conversation. Get in touch with us to discuss how these findings apply to your early careers programme and where we might be able to help.
Crafting a clearer and more consistent candidate journey for Grant Thornton
How Unseen reduced drop-out rates during the process and renege rates post-offer for Grant Thornton.
About the Customer
Organisation
Grant Thornton
Industry
Finance
Use Case
Welcome Hub, offer-to-start candidate experience
Key result
The Hub brought together practical pre-joining guidance, real employee stories, useful tasks and live events in one place. The programme successfully helped candidates feel supported between offer and start date, reducing drop-out and renege rates.
Background
Grant Thornton needed a way to make the transition into work clearer and more consistent for their early careers candidates, reducing drop-out rates during the process and renege rates post-offer. Using Unseen’s candidate experience and onboarding platform, Meet&Engage, they created a Welcome Hub, bringing practical pre-joining guidance, real employee stories, useful tasks, and live events together in one place, helping candidates feel supported before their first day.
“The content is supportive as it allows me to hear about other people’s experiences. I find it more engaging because the information is presented in different formats, such as articles and videos, which makes it easy to follow.” Candidate feedback
Our solution
The Welcome Hub programme focused on the offer-to-start stage. Its aim was to give every new joiner useful information at the right time, build confidence about entering a professional environment, reduce avoidable uncertainty, and keep candidates warm and engaged for up to 10 months between offer and start date.
The content was organised into seven cohort packages:
Graduates
Apprentices
12-month placements
Interns
Placement returners
Apprentice returners
Intern returners
Unseen created tailored content, with candidates receiving practical guidance on topics such as dress code, workplace skills, office information, and what to expect. Videos, welcome content, and real employee stories helped make content relatable.
Content was released gradually, rather than asking candidates to absorb everything at once. Date-based “To-do” posts set out tasks within specific windows, and candidates could tick off completed items. FAQs and a chatbot offered routes to answers outside of working hours. Candidates could receive notifications when new content or responses were available.
Virtual events added direct contact with teams and peers. ‘Ask us anything’ sessions ran in October, November, January, and February, with events totalling just under 300 attendees.
“The content is supportive as it allows me to hear about other people’s experiences. I find it more engaging because the information is presented in different formats, such as articles and videos, which makes it easy to follow.” Candidate feedback
Outcome
The Welcome Hub achieved results, exceeding targets and resulting in a significantly improved candidate experience:
A 94% registration rate, exceeding its 90% target
Candidates returned an average of 14 times, with candidate satisfaction reaching an NPS of 95
100% of respondents saying the content helped them feel supported as they prepared to join
The chatbot received 100% positive smiley-face feedback, with 36% of activity taking place outside office hours
App installation reached 57%, above the 50% target.
Grant Thornton also set a target for at least 75% of new joiners to feel more prepared for a professional environment. The target was met: 75% said they felt more prepared, and the remaining respondents said they felt somewhat prepared. No respondents said they felt unprepared.
“The content is always informative whether that is new information or supplementing existing knowledge. The continued communication is also comforting when waiting to get started!” Candidate feedback
Repeated feedback described the Hub as useful, clear, accessible and easy to navigate. Candidates valued practical advice, regular content releases, the to-do list, FAQs, virtual events, office information and videos. Real experiences from Grant Thornton people helped candidates relate to the transition and feel more confident about joining.
The Hub also reduced the administrative burden on the early careers team by answering common questions and supporting task completion. Sarah Blake, Grant Thornton’s front-line team manager, noted a noticeable reduction in new-starter enquiries to the inbox.
By combining timely guidance with authentic experiences and opportunities to ask questions, the Welcome Hub extended the employer brand beyond recruitment communications, showing candidates both what to do and what joining could feel like and ensuring they were ‘Keeping the Yes’, reducing reneges through creating a more connected, confident and consistent pre-joining experience.
Let’s build potential, together
Share your goals and challenges with our qualified team of assessment experts today.
A psychological analysis of why assessing for today’s AI skills is no longer enough
In a short space of time, the concept of being “good at AI” has changed significantly as the tools have rapidly evolved. For employers, building assessments to understand candidate AI proficiency can therefore feel like chasing a moving target. How can we effectively evidence the skills we need from candidates when the tools are changing so quickly?
Our latest whitepaper by Ben Williams, Chief Scientist at Unseen, introduces the concept of AI Orientation: a more enduring way to explore the motivations, confidence, values and beliefs that shape how people engage with AI; and how to turn those findings into useful assessment evidence.
Knowing what someone can do with AI today does not tell you everything about how they will approach tomorrow’s possibilities. AI Orientation considers the attitudes, motivations and personal boundaries behind that approach which allow us to understand a longer-term view of the individual.
01 / PSYCHOLOGY
The psychology behind AI use
Our research-informed approach brings together three perspectives that offer a richer picture than asking whether someone is “good with AI”; personality, motivation and beliefs & attitudes.
02 / PERSONALITY
What you’re already assessing
We explore how your existing assessments may already be providing the right kinds of evidence about some of the psychological foundations of AI Orientation.
03 / APPLICATION
Applying the approach
The whitepaper looks at how you can apply job analysis to AI-enabled work, the legal considerations and how this can be relevantly applied to selection criteria.
An example from the whitepaper
Understand why people approach AI differently
People with similar AI skills may need different support. AI Orientation explores the dispositions, motivations, attitudes, values and beliefs behind their approach. Open a statement to see how this could shape a
development conversation.
“I don’t think I can learn this.”
Confidence in learning
Willingness and self-belief are not the same.
Someone may want to use AI but doubt their ability to learn.
A supported, manageable task could be more useful than asking
for greater enthusiasm.
A useful starting point: what feels difficult, and what have
previous learning experiences shown?
“I can’t see the point.”
Motivation for AI
Find the purpose, not just the enthusiasm.
Someone does not have to find AI fascinating to have a reason
to use it. Explore whether an appropriate application could
help them achieve an outcome they value.
A useful starting point: what real problem could AI help with,
and what would the trade-offs be?
“I disagree with how it is used.”
Values and beliefs
A concern is not automatically a development need.
An objection might relate to one application, a supplier or a
settled ethical principle. Understand its scope before assuming
that more training will change it.
A useful starting point: which uses feel unacceptable, and would
any safeguards address that concern?
Illustrative development conversations from Beyond AI Literacy.
These are starting points for discussion, not an assessment or a diagnosis.
Inside the whitepaper
A more considered way to understand AI skills
Beyond AI Literacy explores how AI Orientation can inform conversations
about hiring and development, while keeping assessment connected to what
a role actually requires.
✓Look beyond current technical skills to the motivations and beliefs that shape AI use.
✓Consider how existing assessments can be complemented by structured interviews and tailored exercises.
✓Use a more personal starting point for development conversations about AI.
The secret to award-winning candidate experiences that work at scale
Unseen has been named The Candidate Experience Solution of the Year at the TIARA Talent Acquisition & Talent Tech Awards.
Here’s a look behind the curtain at what it takes to make a complex recruitment journey clear, fair and human.
In early careers programmes, high-volume recruitment and wider talent acquisition, employers often struggle with fragmented candidate experiences.
Managing each element of the process across different stages, workstreams and systems can lead to disjointed experiences that affect candidate engagement, role understanding, workplace readiness and ultimately create a gap between the brand employers set out to create and the one that candidates end up experiencing.
Earlier offers and longer lead times can stretch the journey, while greater candidate choice and AI-assisted applications place more pressure on employers to keep those in the pipeline informed and engaged.
It is now more important than ever to deliver a high quality, seamless, and engaging candidate experience. After all the work employers do to attract candidates, commitment can no longer be assumed.
At Unseen, we see candidate experience as more than a series of touchpoints. It is holistic, across every interaction, every interview, and every test. It is shaped by how clearly candidates understand the opportunity, how fairly they can demonstrate their strengths, and how supported they feel as they move towards starting work.
The impact on candidates and hiring teams
Better candidate experience is closely connected to business performance: clearer journeys can strengthen engagement and preparedness, consistent assessment can help hiring teams make more confident decisions and reducing avoidable friction in processes gives teams more time to focus on the people behind each application.
“Winning the Candidate Experience Solution of the Year in the TIARA awards is meaningful recognition of what our teams and clients achieve together. Our submission reflects work across the candidate journey, from authentic employee stories and clearer communication to fairer, more consistent assessment and support from offer through to day one.”
Ali Hackett, CX Director, Unseen
Our success stories include operational and candidate experience measures across different parts of the journey, from candidate preparedness and views of assessment to the practical demands on hiring teams.
At Royal Mail, 94% registered for the onboarding platform, and email enquiries fell by 69%. At Kier Group, graduate recruitment volumes increased by 40%, and all assessors surveyed reported a significant improvement compared with the previous platform. At Toyota GB, candidates rated redesigned assessment-centre exercises 5.48 out of 6 for allowing them to demonstrate their skills and abilities, and 5.71 out of 6 for relevance to the placement.
Together, these results show that candidate experience and operational performance can support one another.
“What matters most to me is the difference this makes for candidates and hiring teams. At Royal Mail, 83% of candidates said they felt more prepared for day one, alongside a 50% reduction in attrition. I’m proud of the expertise and care behind this work, and grateful to our clients for their trust and collaboration.”
Ali Hackett, CX Director, Unseen
A connected approach to candidate experience
Our method at Unseen is to bring together talent strategy, recruitment expertise, vendor-agnostic HR technology advice, assessment science, specialist technology and authentic storytelling to help employers attract, assess, select and onboard people in a practical, scalable and evidence-informed way.
Our award-winning solutions support employers to make their processes easier to navigate without making them feel impersonal, even at scale.
Making the journey work at scale starts with clarity and communication.
Candidates need an honest sense of the organisation and role, and support that continues beyond the initial application. Seenit helps employers bring employee stories into attraction, while Meet&Engage supports clear communication and onboarding.
Assessment needs to be relevant to the role and consistent for every candidate.
Our assessment psychologists help define what good looks like and shape the exercises, with Evolve Assess enabling bespoke tools such as SJTs and psychometrics. Oneway supports smoother
digital interviewing and selection experiences, reducing friction and improving consistency. ,while TopScore supports delivery at scale.
Your strategy and tools need to be scalable and tailored.
For early careers programmes, Ladder brings recruitment and delivery expertise, and Udder helps employers select and implement HR technology that fits their needs.
All of our capabilities have distinct roles, but candidates experience one journey. Taken together, the experience is one that is easier for candidates to navigate and more effective for employers to deliver.
Better candidate experiences, built together
This award is an endorsement of the practical work we do with our partners: making complex hiring journeys work better for candidates and employers. We are incredibly proud of this achievement and thankful to the employers we work with who are just as committed as we are to delivering industry-leading candidate experiences.
More importantly, we will keep working with employers to build talent journeys that are scalable, fair and human, and give candidates a clearer, more considered experience from first interaction to day one.
In this webinar, Ben Williams, Chief Scientist at Unseen, dives into our whitepaper, Beyond AI Literacy, which introduces the concept of AI Orientation.
He explores why assessing today’s AI skills is not enough, and how understanding people’s motivations, confidence and boundaries can inform hiring and development.
People responsible for hiring, assessing or developing talent as AI changes how we work.
What we discuss
How the whitepaper’s approach can help you assess AI readiness beyond current technical skills.
An example from the whitepaper
Understand why people approach AI differently
People with similar AI skills may need different support. AI Orientation
explores the dispositions, motivations, attitudes, values and beliefs
behind their approach. Open a statement to see how this could shape a
development conversation.
“I don’t think I can learn this.”
Confidence in learning
Willingness and self-belief are not the same.
Someone may want to use AI but doubt their ability to learn.
A supported, manageable task could be more useful than asking
for greater enthusiasm.
A useful starting point: what feels difficult, and what have
previous learning experiences shown?
“I can’t see the point.”
Motivation for AI
Find the purpose, not just the enthusiasm.
Someone does not have to find AI fascinating to have a reason
to use it. Explore whether an appropriate application could
help them achieve an outcome they value.
A useful starting point: what real problem could AI help with,
and what would the trade-offs be?
“I disagree with how it is used.”
Values and beliefs
A concern is not automatically a development need.
An objection might relate to one application, a supplier or a
settled ethical principle. Understand its scope before assuming
that more training will change it.
A useful starting point: which uses feel unacceptable, and would
any safeguards address that concern?
Illustrative development conversations from Beyond AI Literacy.
These are starting points for discussion, not an assessment or a diagnosis.
What you’ll take away
A more useful view of AI readiness
01
Understand what sits behind AI use
Distinguish technical capability from motivation, self-belief and
ethical boundaries, without reducing people to an enthusiasm score.
02
Build on your existing assessments
Explore what personality questionnaires already cover, and where
structured interviews and tailored exercises can add evidence.
03
Make development more personal
Identify the conversation each person needs, while keeping assessment
grounded in what their role actually requires.
It’s always been the way that hiring teams have separated recruitment into different stages, systems and workstreams, but candidates navigate and experience processes in a much more continuous, even linear, way.
While you’re busy deciding if the candidate is the right fit for your organisation, they’re deciding whether your organisation is the right fit for them. Psychologically, people make inferences about what it will be like to work somewhere based on their experiences during recruitment. This means that every stage of your journey can either strengthen or weaken the story you are trying to tell about your organisation – and while each team across your stages could be doing a brilliant job, the overall candidate experience can still feel fragmented or inconsistent.
By looking into the psychology of the candidate as they move through the journey, we can better understand them and find practical ways to make things feel joined up, even when different technologies, teams and suppliers sit behind different stages.
Stage 1
Attraction
What the candidate is thinking:
Can I see myself there?
When candidates look at the people already working in an organisation,
they are imagining a future version of themselves.
The Recruiter Problem
The right people don’t apply, or candidates apply with the wrong
expectations.
You will already be aware of the importance of representation in your
marketing and attraction, but can your candidates genuinely identify
with the people and stories they’re seeing?
Candidates are savvy enough to know that employer brand content is designed to persuade them. So if every employee uses the same, scripted language, it can be difficult to hear the person behind the message which can impact authenticity.
Our upcoming report, The Science of Employee Generated Content, dives into the power behind this and the credibility that individuality brings to your employer brand during the attraction stage.
Look for ways to give employees the freedom and confidence to tell their own stories, like through user generated content that they take the lead on. This could take the form of videos or posts shared on social, blog posts, thought pieces, or articles for the company website, or sharing professional milestones on LinkedIn. It can also be worth looking into different platforms that can help the team to create, for example Seenit guides and supports employees from start to finish in creating authentic testimonials in their own voices, even if being on camera isn’t something they’re used to.
Stage 2
Keep warm communications
What the candidate is thinking:
Is this worth continuing?
Now they’re in the process, candidates are deciding whether to keep investing their time and attention.
The Recruiter Problem
Good candidates lose interest, disengage or drop out.
Several things can raise red flags for candidates, with silence being the first. If there are delays or gaps in communication, without any context given, candidates will worry and fill those silences with their own stories, wondering whether they have failed or been forgotten.
Ensure you’re giving candidates clear communication deliberately at the moments where uncertainty is most likely to grow, rather than just increasing your volume of communications overall.
CIPD and Omni RMS reported in 2024 that 27% of UK employers recruiting in the previous year had experienced a new starter simply failing to turn up on Day One.
We recently outlined four key principles exploring science-backed approaches to this stage in the recruitment process, backed up by real examples of how to apply them shared by Holly Pearce, Grant Thornton’s Talent and Recruitment Experience Manager, in our blog. For practical strategies to reduce reneges and make sure your candidates are ready to join your team, read the full article here.
Stage 3
Assessment
What the candidate is thinking:
Can I show you what I can do?
Candidates naturally form judgements about whether an assessment seems connected to the job and whether it feels like a reasonable way of making a decision about them.
The Recruiter Problem
Poorly designed or inconsistently delivered assessment can drive drop-out, distort performance and lead to poorer hiring decisions.
Ensure you explain what you are assessing and why it matters to the role.
Difficulty should also be purposeful. An assessment should be challenging because the capability being assessed is challenging, not because the instructions are unclear, the interface is awkward or the time limit has not been properly tested.
It’s also important to think about the team delivering the assessment and how their behaviour can affect fairness and consistency, as this can impact how attractive the company feels at this stage in the journey.
Stage 4
Preboarding and Onboarding
What the candidate is thinking:
Have I made the right choice?
Once a candidate receives and accepts an offer, the judgements and decision-making don’t stop there. Candidates may still be comparing opportunities, responding to a counteroffer or looking for reassurance that they have made the right choice.
The Recruiter Problem
Candidates accept offers, then renege, fail to show or disengage early.
Ensure your preboarding creates reassurance, connection and preparedness. Ahead of day one, share useful information and create opportunities to build connections (either in-person or virtually) to help candidates feel more engaged and prepared.
On day one, it’s important that the experience matches what you promised the candidate during attraction and recruitment.
If candidates were told they would have a voice, give them opportunities to contribute. If they were shown a close-knit team, introduce them to that team as soon as possible. If development was part of the recruitment story, show them how learning is supported. It may seem obvious, but ensuring these things are joined up can have a really positive impact post-offer.
Four psychological judgements, one relationship
Every stage of your journey has the potential to change what a candidate thinks of your organisation. The challenge isn’t simply to optimise attraction, communications, assessment and onboarding independently. It’s to make sure they tell a consistent story.
What story does your candidate journey tell?
If you’re reviewing how your organisation attracts, assesses, hires and onboards talent, make sure to download your free copy of The Science of the Candidate Experience; to learn how to deliver better preboarding and onboarding through technology and behavioural science.
Want to learn more about Unseen? Get in touch with us today.
How to deliver better preboarding and onboarding through technology and behavioural science.
Unseen’s Science of… Series
The science behind a better candidate journey
The period between offer acceptance and Day One is often treated as an administrative waiting room.
Increasingly, however, research and practical experience suggest it is something far more important: a critical phase in which candidates begin forming expectations, relationships, confidence and emotional attachment to their future employer.
The second report in our ‘Science of…’ series, in The Science of the Candidate Experience, Ben Williams, Chief Scientist at Unseen Group and a Chartered Occupational Psychologist, explores how to deliver better preboarding and onboarding through technology and behavioural science.
Science-backed principles of psychologically informed preboarding journeys
02
How to create experiences that feel personal to candidates while remaining manageable at scale
03
Understand what you need to continuously improve the candidate journey over time
“
Attention is fragmented, expectations are evolving and candidates are continually exposed to competing opportunities.
The organisations that succeed in this environment are increasingly those that treat preboarding not as a communication exercise, but as a transition experience.
Ben Williams, Chief Scientist, Unseen Group
Read the full report
Discover how to deliver better preboarding and onboarding through technology and behavioural science.
Four behavioural science principles for reducing early talent reneges.
Ben Williams
Chief Scientist, Unseen Group
The time between offer acceptance and a candidate’s first day is fragile, but keeping them committed to joining your organisation can feel like a tricky task.
Our latest webinar, in partnership with Grant Thornton, explored science-backed approaches to reducing reneges and making sure your candidates are ready to join your team.
With expert insights from Unseen’s Chief Scientist, Ben Williams, and Head of Partnerships, Nicola Sullivan, along with Grant Thornton’s Talent and Recruitment Experience Manager, Holly Pearce, in this article we share the four core principles they recommend hiring teams follow to design better, more engaging, candidate journeys.
Why commitment can waver after an offer
When a candidate accepts your job offer, it’s not necessarily the end of the hiring journey. They’re often still asking: will I fit in, can I do the job and what will my first day be like?
Economic uncertainty, the cost of living, social media, constant communication, and AI have all changed the way in which early talent decisions are made. Candidates have access to more information, more comparison points, and more reasons to reconsider than ever before.
To keep the “yes”, employers need to design a candidate journey that strengthens their commitment.
The following four principles of behavioural science, backed up by real examples, provide practical strategies for hiring teams.
Principle 1: Create opportunities for commitment
Keeping candidates engaged with your brand can stop them being enticed by others. After candidates have accepted your offer, build momentum by setting up opportunities for meaningful micro-commitments.
At Grant Thornton, Holly’s team does this through their Meet&Engage Hub, which allows them to drip feed content and updates to candidates between offer and start date to keep them feeling excited and engaged.
The response from candidates has been brilliant:
“It was great to get support throughout each stage of the recruitment process. Knowing I could reach out and ask a question at any time was really reassuring!”
Candidate Feedback
Other micro-commitments to help candidates stay connected to the decision they have made and begin to picture themselves in the role might include:
Filling out onboarding paperwork
Completing a pre-work assignment
Joining a pre-start event
Chatting to a future colleague or buddy
Principle 2: Reduce uncertainty
If your candidates don’t know what the role involves, who they will work with, or what to expect on day one, commitment is bound to become fragile.
“Silence creates stories. By systematically removing ambiguity and reducing unknowns, you remove any reason to panic or jump ship.”
Ben Williams, Chief Scientist, Unseen
The fewer unknowns candidates have about the job, the less anxiety they will feel. Clear, timely sharing of information helps remove the silence that allows anxiety and assumptions to grow.
Often candidates are wondering about very practical things:
Where do I go and what should I wear?
Who will meet me?
What will my first few weeks involve?
Where can I go for help?
When we looked at data from our Meet&Engage platform, we found that candidates engage most with video content from the new joiners the year before them, specifically when they answered “What do I wish I knew ahead of day one?”.
Direct conversations, websites, chatbots and engagement platforms that share this sort of information in a friendly, human way can help candidates feel prepared and supported.
Holly shared that, at Grant Thorton, they tailor their careers website to every different group that engages, across students, parents, career break returners, and so on, to make sure every audience has the information they need.
As well as this, they use the Meet&Engage chatbot function programmed with their FAQs to support candidates whenever they have a question, with responses accessible to candidates even outside of core hours.
Principle 3: Build a sense of belonging
Candidates stay committed when they can see themselves as part of the organisation. Relationships with recruiters, buddies, future managers, and peers can make the opportunity feel personal and connected.
Belonging works best when it feels genuine. In-person events, authentic employee stories, and thoughtful buddying can help candidates connect with real people to see where they fit best. Employee content platforms such as Seenit enable employees to easily create authentic and compelling content to support engagement.
“Candidates are very quick to see through anything that feels overly corporate. Belonging only really works when it feels genuine.”
Holly Pearce, Talent and Recruitment Experience Manager, Grant Thorton
At Grant Thornton, Holly and her team utilise “Smart buddying”, where they set up a connection based on what’s most likely to help each candidate. This could mean pairing women with female colleagues in male-dominated teams, connecting candidates with someone from the same university, or introducing them to someone who has faced a similar offer decision.
The Grant Thornton team aim to meet their incoming candidates face-to-face as much as they can before their first day, to help them feel part of something bigger and start to picture themselves in the role.
“At scale, it’s easy to forget how powerful simply being human and responsive can be.”
Nicola Sullivan, Head of Partnerships, Unseen
Principle 4: Boost confidence
One of the biggest drivers of disengagement is confidence – and the lack of it. Candidates are often asking themselves: can I actually do this?
People choose environments they think they will succeed in and avoid those where they think they won’t. Employers can build confidence early by giving candidates small wins before day one, for example:
Give useful feedback on their assessment scores
Set a low-stakes pre-join task and provide praise upon completion
Share stories of people with similar backgrounds who have succeeded
Coaching and feedback throughout the hiring process can also help candidates understand how they are progressing and feel more ready to start.
“Candidates confidence is at an all time low. We feel as early careers recruiters that we have a duty of care to manage that.”
Holly Pearce, Talent and Recruitment Experience Manager, Grant Thorton
Grant Thornton offers coaching at every stage of the process, including phone calls with one of their experienced recruiters.
A practical framework for employers
Taken together, these four principles help us to understand why commitment wavers, predict candidate engagement, and design better journeys for between offer and start date:
#1
Commitment: What meaningful action are we inviting the candidate to take?
#2
Certainty: What questions or unknowns might still be present?
#3
Belonging: Who is helping the candidate feel part of the organisation?
#4
Confidence: What evidence are we giving them that they can succeed?
Reducing early talent reneges is about helping candidates make an informed choice, then supporting that choice with practical information, genuine relationships and a human-first approach.
Interested to hear more?
Enter your details below to access the full webinar, where you’ll learn how to apply these principles to your post-offer engagement strategy.